Jesus

Is God’s Love Reckless? A Long Overdue and Mostly Superfluous Review of Cory Asbury’s Smash Hit ‘Reckless Love’

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment

It had to be done.

I simply could not claim to write a theological worship song review blog without confronting the greatest worship controversy of our age: Is God’s love reckless? I doubt our pal Cory knew what a can of worms he was opening when he and his coauthors penned “Reckless Love,” but now that I’ve seen his TikToks, I’m pretty sure he eats cans of worms for breakfast and would gladly do it all over again.

So: “Reckless Love.” Cory Asbury, Caleb Culver, and Ran Jackson. Biblical or heretical? Should you sing it in church or walk out as soon as you hear that electric guitar lead line? Will it worship?? Here goes.

Focus

The two themes of this song are God’s relentless love and the humble response of the undeserving recipient. I wouldn’t call this song self-centered, but it is very focused on the love relationship between the individual and the Lord.

What are the main themes of the song? Is it God-centered or me-centered? How does it address God?

Lyric Analysis

THE DEEPLY THEOLOGICAL VERSES
Verse 1 draws together ideas from Zephaniah 3:17, Genesis 2:7, Psalm 139:13-16, and Jeremiah 1:5. God knows us before we are born, even before we are conceived. He gives us life, delights in us, sings over us! Even before we exist, our Father is drawing us into his story.

If the first verse is about God loving us before we are even born, verse 2 is about his love for us before we come to know and love Jesus. Romans 5:8-10 and Ephesians 2:1-5 teach us that before we believed, we were dead in our sins, alienated from the life of God, enslaved both by our own passions and oppressive demonic forces, living as God’s enemies. But even while we were in this state, Christ died to reconcile us to God!

When the world or our own fears tell us we are worthless, Jesus says that he gave the very highest price to buy us back from slavery: himself. (Titus 2:14)

THE UNRELENTING BRIDGE
I’m going out of order. Sorry. šŸ¤· In the bridge, Jesus be climbing up walls, kicking down mountains, and lighting up shadows to come after me. Or something like that.

Jesus’ divine nature as the Light of the World is a recurring theme in Scripture. John 1:5 says, “The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not overtake it.” This is part of a longer description of Christ’s incarnation, his humble entry into the world of flesh to make God known to us and invite us into his family. So he lights up shadows in pursuit of us. John also ties Jesus’ identity as the Light to his identity as the Truth. As love casts out fear (1 Jn 4:18), so truth casts out lies (Eph 4:25), and Jesus’ light tears down the lies that would prevent us from being drawn into his family.

I can’t think of any specific examples of Jesus climbing a mountain to reach us, but I take this as a metaphor for the many obstacles he overcame in order to extend his love to us, especially the cross and the humiliating death he willingly endured there (Heb 12:2, Ph 2:8). Ephesians 2:13-15 tells us that he tore down the walls between people (hostility) and between humanity and God (the Law) in his own flesh on the cross.

I think the bridge comes off a little bit Calvinist, which could be a good or bad thing depending on your tradition and beliefs. The idea of God kicking down every wall to come after me does feel a bit like the doctrine of irresistible grace, though it stops short of fully taking that position.

THE RECKLESS CHORUS
While the title of this song is indeed “Reckless Love,” “reckless” is just one of many adjectives applied to God’s love here in the chorus. I don’t even think it’s the most important one. The best song titles highlight what is unique about a song, not necessarily the most important point the song makes. There are lots of songs about how God’s love is overwhelming and unending, but this is the first mainstream worship hit to make use of the word “reckless,” and it certainly makes a splash.

Especially when taken together with the verses and bridge, this chorus is about how God’s love will overcome every obstacle to pursue us wherever we are. It characterizes the love God displays throughout Jesus’ parables in Luke 15. The father of the Prodigal Son exposes himself to ridicule by running out to meet his son. The son is overwhelmed. A woman spends costly oil and crawls around her house to find her lost coin. She won’t quit until it’s found. And (as specifically referenced in the song), the shepherd who loses one sheep abandons his 99 others in pursuit of the one missing. Reckless behavior perhaps? These parables show the intense love of God the Father for those who are lost from him.

Referring to the worshiper, this song says, “I couldn’t earn it, I don’t deserve it, still You give Yourself away.” Ephesians 2:8-9 teaches us that God’s grace and salvation (inextricably tied to his love) are free gifts, not anything we could earn. “Deserve” is a tricky word, and I think there is a sense in which we deserve God’s love and a sense in which we don’t. Fortunately, this line is explained in verse 2: “When I was your foe, still your love fought for me.” Our natural state apart from God is to be enslaved in our sin, and our only earned or deserved relationship to him is that of an enemy. Still, God extends his love to us. He has made us in his image, called us into his family, and shown our inestimable worth to him through his sacrifice on the cross.

BUT IS IT RECKLESS THOUGH???
As Pilate asks, “What is truth” (Jn 18:38) so we must ask, “What is reckless?” Merriam-Webster gives two definitions, but one of them is a two-parter, so let’s call it three:

  1. Marked by a lack of proper caution
  2. Careless of consequences
  3. Irresponsible

I think when people get hung up on this word in this song, they are primarily thinking of definition #3. God is certainly not irresponsible. Jesus isn’t a reckless driver, a kid who didn’t do his homework, or a gambling addict who lost it all on the ponies and can’t feed his family. I’m going to go out on a limb and suggest that no reasonable person, Christian or otherwise, would hear the words of this song and think that’s the kind of recklessness the author intends to ascribe to our Lord.

There’s a case to be made for #1, since a constant criticism the Pharisees had for Jesus was that he didn’t show proper caution in associating with sinners, healing on the Sabbath, and acting like he had authority to forgive sins.

But I think the definition closest to Cory, Caleb, and Ran’s meaning here is #2. God knew exactly what the consequences of pursuing us to the cross with his love would be, and he didn’t care. He did it anyway. If I see my daughter run out in front of a train, and I leap onto the tracks to shove her out of the way, no one would criticize the preacher at my funeral for calling that a reckless act of love. So it seems perfectly appropriate to me to call Christ’s incarnation and ultimate sacrifice acts of reckless love.

“But Jason!” you say, “‘Recklessness’ is still bad! We mustn’t tarnish God’s reputation with words bearing negative connotations!”

My response is that the Bible itself uses negative words and exaggeration for effect, even when describing God! God loves Jacob and hates Esau (Rm 9:13). Jesus tells us that we have to hate our mothers, fathers, spouses, children, and our own lives to be his disciples (Lk 14:26). In 1 Corinthians 1:25, Paul has the audacity to say, “Godā€™s foolishness is wiser than human wisdom, and Godā€™s weakness is stronger than human strength.” God foolish and weak? Blasphemy!

The same understanding of poetic language and figures of speech that allows us to make sense of these passages also enables us to call God’s love reckless without distorting the truth of his wisdom and foresight.

So, yes! God’s love is reckless. And, no! God’s love isn’t exactly reckless. But the word has great poetic value in the unique and poignant way it captures Christ’s willing self-sacrifice.

(For a counterpoint to my view, John Piper raises some concerns about this word, even while rejoicing in how Calvinistic many of the lyrics are. He brings up the theology of open theism in which God chooses not to know what all of our individual choices will be and suggests that the word “reckless” implies this theology. I think that’s a huge leap.)

Accessibility

The only people who misinterpret this song are established Christians who have a theological objection to calling God’s love reckless. The language is quite transparent except for the phrase “leaves the 99,” which means nothing unless you’re familiar with the parable it refers to.

To be honest, this song is a little tricky to sing, mostly due to rhythm and prosody. The range is an octave+5, which is a little wide but also typical for contemporary worship. In practice, I have found that congregations are more than happy to learn the melody and belt this song out. (And at this point, everyone probably knows it already.)

Music

One thing I love about this song is its musical versatility. You can sing it with a worship band, an orchestra, or just a piano. For example, the iconic opening lead line works great on almost any instrument. The dynamics and chord progression follow the typical worship song patterns, but they’re classic for a reason. There’s a good build through the bridge, and the chorus works great loud and soft.

The thing that sets this song apart musically is the way dotted eighth note melody of the chorus and lead line sits on top of the 6/8 beat. The melody feels like it’s in 4/4 even though it’s not, and this offers some really cool musical tension that pulls you forward through the song. It also offers a challenge for drummers! The only solution I have is to encourage your musicians to listen to this song on repeat for a while until they really internalize the underlying beat and the main melody and how they fit together.

Function

Gathering | Word | Table | Sending

This one works best in the middle of a worship service. It is intimate and communicates both the truth of God’s love to us and our humble and needy (in a good way!) response to him.

It would be super cool to use this song immediately following a reading or dramatic presentation of any of the Luke 15 parables.

Conclusions

Will it worship? Of course it will! This is a powerful worship anthem that has expressed the love of God in a fresh way to a whole generation. It’s accessible, deep, mostly singable, and teaches biblical truth. I am thoroughly convinced that no one has ever learned any bad theology from this song, and I remain in awe at the reckless love of our Savior.

Image by Vital Sinkevich on Unsplash

Scripture quotations are taken from the New Revised Standard Version Updated Edition. Copyright Ā© 2021 National Council of Churches of Christ in the United States of America. Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.

Exploring ‘Long Live the King’: A Worship Analysis

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment

“Long Live the King,” written by Gabriel Wilson, Matt Gilman, and Nate Lapeer, seized my attention when it came out two years ago. Its vivid and theological description of Jesus’ death, resurrection, and exaltation brought me to tears in my car. It impressed the majesty and glory of Christ on my heart and imagination in a way that few songs have.

I learned it, practiced it, and was all geared up to use it for Easter 2023! Unfortunately, the third verse weirded me out. My church doesn’t really teach that Jesus descended into hell while he was in the grave, and I thought that event, the Harrowing of Hell, is what this verse was referring to. I chickened out, and we haven’t used it for church. But now I’m ready to give “Long Live the King” another look! What is that funky third verse about, is it biblical, and will it worship? Let’s check it out!

Focus

“Long Live the King” is an acclamation of Christ. It explores his suffering, death, resurrection, and glorification and hails him as king in each context.

It calls Jesus by name and uses lots of titles for him including Anointed One, Emmanuel, and Perfect Lamb. It also refers to the Holy Spirit’s role in Jesus’ resurrection. The language in “Long Live the King” is both personal and corporate; each chorus talks about lifting my hands, but the verses speak of our Messiah, our Redeemer, our victory.

Lyric Analysis

VERSES 1 & 2
These verses are sung back-to-back and recount the same events from two different perspectives.

Verse 1 is about the physical events of Jesus’ suffering, death, and burial. It picks out several significant events from John 19, so we’ll start with the crown of thorns. The writers do something really cool here by saying, “There in crown of thorn and thistle.” At first, I thought this was just a poetic liberty. After all, the crown in the Gospels only had thorns. No thistles to be seen. But where do we find thorns and thistles together in the Bible? Genesis 3:18 says of the ground, “thorns and thistles it shall bring forth for you.” Adam’s work is made painful and dangerous because of sin. In his death, Jesus is taking Adam’s curse upon his own head. This is something verse 2 makes explicit.

The rest of the verse recounts more familiar details: the sign reading “King of the Jews,” Jesus’ blood shed on the cross, the crimson river flowing from his pierced side, darkness falling at his death, the burial clothes, and Jesus’ interment in a tomb. This verse invites us to contemplate Christ’s suffering and humiliation. When we do, we find both grief and gratitude welling up within us.

Verse 2 deals with the spiritual realities of Christ’s work on the cross. The first line echoes the metaphor of Adam’s thorns and thistles: every curse is laid upon Christ. He bears the burden for us. He wears our sin like the robe of shame the soldiers placed on him.

Calling Jesus the “perfect Lamb led to the slaughter” recalls the words of Isaiah 53:7, “He was oppressed, and he was afflicted, yet he opened not his mouth; like a lamb that is led to the slaughter.” It also looks forward to Revelation 5:5-6, where John is told to look for the Lion, but instead finds the slain Lamb standing. This song will show us both Jesus’ humble sacrifice as a lamb and his triumphant power as a lion.

In the Old Testament, a ransom was the price paid to save someone’s life, either from slavery or from the just punishment for a crime they had committed. This is what Christ has done for us. At the moment of his death, Jesus tore the temple veil in two (Lk 23:44-46). This was the curtain that sealed off the Holy of Holies, the place where God’s presence rested. It represented the great divide between God and man, the rift between our sinfulness and his holiness. Christ’s death was a great victory because he accomplished all this, defeating sin and darkness, freeing us from our enslavement to death, and bringing us safely into God’s holy presence. Revelation 12:11 teaches us that the victory of the saints is in the blood of the Lamb.

LONG LIVE THE KING
There is no single chorus in this song. Instead, each chorus has its own words that develop what was discussed in the preceding verse. The one commonality is the repeated titular phrase: “Long live the King!”

People have been wishing long life to their rulers for millennia. “Long live the king” was the shout of the people when Samuel anointed Saul and proclaimed him king (1 Sam 10:24). Daniel even addresses King Darius, a pagan ruler, this way (Dan 6:21). To say “long live the king” is to express loyalty and submission to a ruler. It’s a statement of belief that they are the rightful and beneficial sovereign. It is an endorsement of their justice and righteousness.

In Western culture, “long live the king” is often part of the longer phrase “The king is dead, long live the king!” Traditionally, this is the announcement of the death of the former ruler and the succession of the new one. In the context of Jesus’ death, it means something completely different! It is in his dying that he is crowned and exalted.

How appropriate, then, to proclaim “long live the king” of Christ Jesus, of whom Isaiah says, “Of the increase of his government and of peace there will be no end, on the throne of David and over his kingdom, to establish it and to uphold it with justice and with righteousness from this time forth and forevermore!” (Is 9:7)

CHORUS 1
The first line of this chorus says, “the wrath of God and man now satisfied.” Many people are uncomfortable with songs that mention God’s wrath, or the idea that Jesus satisfies it. They object to the idea that a loving God should have any wrath toward his children and therefore the idea that he should send his Son to absorb such wrath on our behalf. I sympathize with their concerns, but we need to take the problem of human evil seriously if we are going to discuss God’s wrath. How can we look at genocides, murders, rapes, systemic racism, oppression of the poor, and casual acts of violence and not cry out for justice? How can we not cry out for God’s wrath to wash away the wicked? We must also remember that Jesus is not a separate entity from God; he is not merely human. He is God himself. So if one seek to blame God for creating man with our capacity for wickedness or if you think God is unjust to punish evil, remember that he stepped into our suffering and pain and took his own wrath upon himself. (Rom 2:8, Rom 3:23, 2 Cor 5:21, Gal 3:10-13, Isa 53:4-11) I think this is an excellent line because it shows that while God’s wrath is just, it is no longer directed toward us us because of Christ’s atonement. I also love that it draws the wrath of man into the equation. We humans so easily become wroth with one another, but Jesus’ death disarms our anger and violence. Ephesians 2:14 teaches that Christ broke down the dividing walls between people as well as the wall between us and God. In the shadow of the cross, how can we raise a hand against our brother or sister?

The phrase “he paid the price” echoes the early church’s understanding of atonement, called “ransom theory.” (Think Aslan dying to ransom Edmund in The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe.) In the Old Testament, atonement for all the people was made with continual sacrifices. Jesus has made perfect and final atonement once and for all by the sacrifice of his own body and blood (Heb 10:10).

Even sin and sickness must obey Jesus. He healed countless people during his ministry, including casting out demons (Mt 8:16-17). In the story of the paralyzed man in Matthew 9:1-8, he demonstrates his lordship over both. Not only does he forgive all the man’s sins, but he heals his body as evidence of his authority. It is important that we remember that while every sin and sickness must submit to Jesus’ authority, we are not guaranteed individual victory over each sin and sickness in our lifetime. There are sins that will continue to tempt us until we die, and each of us will eventually succumb to sickness. Even the Apostle Paul dealt with his famous “thorn in the flesh,” a persistent ailment of some kind (2 Cor 12:7). We must not take someone’s continued illness or struggle with temptation as evidence of lack of faith or evidence that God is absent.

VERSE 3
This verse is a little confusing because it could refer to a couple different things. It references several Scriptures, but the verses in question are famously hard to understand. We could be talking about the Harrowing of Hell, or we could be speaking more generally about Jesus defeating death.

In ancient Greek thought, Hades was where all the dead went, not only the wicked. It doesn’t carry the same connotations of evil and punishment as the Christian idea of hell. (Side note: Can we all agree to sing “depths of Hades” instead of “bowels of Hades?” I would really rather not say “bowels” in a worship song. šŸ¤¢) The trembling in Hades could refer to the twin earthquakes at Christ’s death and resurrection (Mt 27:54, Mt 28:2), or it could refer to death and hell themselves quaking in fear at Christ’s victory. The breath of God descending could refer to the Holy Spirit entering Christ’s tomb to bring him back to life (Rom 8:10-11), or to Jesus entering the realm of the dead to proclaim his Gospel to all the dead (1 Pet 3:18-20).

The triumphal parade seems to be a reference to Ephesians 4:8-9, which says, “When he ascended on high he led a host of captives, and he gave gifts to men. (In saying, ‘He ascended,’ what does it mean but that he had also descended into the lower regions, the earth?).” Rather than a parade of captured enemies, as commonly seen in a Roman triumph or even in Psalm 68:8, Jesus is leading a procession of liberated captives. This procession consists of everyone who will believe in him, past, present, and future.

Either way you interpret it, this verse uses poetic and scriptural language to show the triumph of Jesus over death.

CHORUS 2
Now, instead of a the mockery and pain of a crown of thorns, Jesus, the Son of God, is crowned with many crowns. This line comes from Revelation 19:12 and also the famous hymn “Crown Him with Many Crowns.”

Jesus is the light of the world who dispels darkness and defeats death (Jn 8:12, 1 Cor 15:22-26). We would be lost in darkness on our own, but instead we are found in his light.

Another potential source of controversy in this song is the line “the souls of every sinner now redeemed.” The question here is whether this line suggests Christian universalism or universal reconciliation, the belief that all people will be saved, not only those who come to believe in Jesus during their earthly lives. I don’t think this line necessarily teaches that. The line says every sinner is redeemed, not that every sinner is saved. To redeem or ransom someone (see verse 2) means to pay a price for that person’s rescue or liberation. Jesus has paid the price for the redemption of every human being. Some may reject him and flee from him, like Hosea’s redeemed wife left him, but this does not lessen the scope of Christ’s great redemption.

VERSE 4
The Bible doesn’t give us much information about what happened inside Jesus’ tomb. We don’t know all the ins and outs of the trinitarian relationship, but it seems evident that the Holy Spirit played a major role in the Resurrection. Romans 8:10-12 says, “if Christ is in you, although the body is dead because of sin, the Spirit is life because of righteousness. If the Spirit of him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, he who raised Christ Jesus from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through his Spirit who dwells in you.” Genesis 2:7 says that when God was making the world, Adam became a living creature when the breath of life entered nostrils. So Christ’s resurrection, the breath of life reentering his lifeless body, is the moment when the New Adam inaugurates the New Creation.

The dual image of Christ as Lion and Lamb is found throughout Scripture, but especially Revelation 5:5-6. Jesus has given his life as the sacrificial Lamb and he has triumphed over death as the glorious Lion of Judah. He is alive and glorified!

CHORUS 3
The name Emmanuel means “God with us,” so it’s interesting that the songwriters use this title here, at the height of Jesus’ glorification in heaven. Even when he is so very far above us, so enthroned that the very stars worship him, he is still near to us.

Much as he has exchanged a crown of thorns for many crowns of glory, Jesus has exchanged the mocking robe of the soldiers for one of true rulership. In Revelation 19:11-16, Jesus rides at the head of the armies of heaven wearing a robe dipped in blood and bearing the name “King of Kings and Lord of Lords.” His reign and victory are just, faithful, and true. None is more worthy, none is more powerful. This enthronement of the Lion/Lamb King is the event for which all of creation has been longing (Rom 8:18-22). The stars and all of creation erupt in worship, and when we sing this song, we join in with them (Ps 148), declaring “long live the King!”

Accessibility

This song has a lot of words and Scripture references, but it also paints really clear and beautiful mental images that anyone can latch onto. For instance, the final chorus references Revelation 19, Romans 8, and Psalm 148, but you don’t have to know those passages to be able to picture the resurrected King Jesus filling heaven with his presence and taking his rightful place on the throne.

The main concern I have for misinterpretation is that some people might take the line, “every sinner now redeemed” as a statement of universal reconciliation, which most Christian churches do not teach. It’s also possible for people to get hung up on the intricacies of verse 3, but I’m confident that is a tangle that only experienced church people will stumble into, and if anything it will lead them into deeper study of God’s word.

The constant refrain, “Long live the King!” is easy to pick up (though the melody gets kinda funky in the second half of the song). The verses repeat the same melodic material over and over, so I think it will be easy for a congregation to learn and sing. The choruses are a little trickier, but well within the bounds of what is congregational. The melody jumps around quite a bit (slightly more than two octaves šŸ˜¬), so range may be a concern. Still, the majority of it stays within an octave+2, so I don’t think you’ll lose people except on the very highest and lowest notes.

Music

The music of this song matches the words perfectly. The beginning is somber, then becomes hopeful, driving, and finally triumphant. And man is that ending triumphant! This is one of my very favorite expressions of the glory of the ascended Son of Man, and it has brought me to tears more than once. Having said all that, dynamics are super important in this song. It’s got to start quiet, it’s got to drive hard through the middle build, and it’s got to have a big ending.

The chord structure is another one of my favorite features of this song. It largely uses the chords you expect in worship songs and pop music, but it also throws in a couple minor 5s and flat 6s that somehow open up the tonality to invoke a level of majesty that you just don’t get in your typical G D Em C worship progression.

With those funky chords, the crazy dynamics, and the wide vocal range, this song demands a lot of a worship band, and it’s not for the faint of heart.

Function

Gathering | Word | Table | Sending

I would use this song anywhere in a worship service except for the very end. It unites God’s people with a shared acclamation, it declares the story of Jesus’ death, resurrection, and glorification, and it provides us with an opportunity to respond to that story from our hearts with love, devotion, and awe. So it works well as an opening song, a song of the Word, or a Communion/response song. The tricky part is fitting it into the dynamic or energy level flow of a service, since it starts so quietly and ends huge.

I would resist the temptation to use this one as a closer. The ending is big and powerful and exciting, but it lacks the kind of call-to-action that makes for an effective sending song.

Conclusions

Will it worship? You bet!

I started writing this post several months ago, before schoolwork and life circumstances necessitated taking a break from blogging. Since then we have sung “Long Live the King” a few times in church, beginning on Easter. I found that people were profoundly moved by the song, though it was more difficult than average for a congregant to learn and be able to sing along.

So, if your band is up for a challenge and you don’t mind some challenging lyrics about Jesus defeating hell, go for it! I am confident this song will bless your congregation and facilitate their heartfelt response to the gospel and the glory of Jesus.

Image by Tom Gainor on Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

Promises or Prosperity? A Biblical Analysis of ‘The Lord Will Provide’

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment

Zack Shelton introduced me to “The Lord Will Provide” (Brett Younker, Chris Davenport, and Jess Cates) at ICYC last year, and I have to confess a little hesitation toward it in the beginning! Songs about God’s promise to provide for us often feel weird to me. We don’t sing them often in my church, in part because we are concerned about the false promises of the prosperity gospel, and we don’t want anyone to get the wrong idea. But after hearing several hundred students belt out their trust in the Lord to this song, my heart softened! And the truth is, God does promise to provide for our needs and answer our prayers.

So the question is: does this song offer us a valuable way to express trust in God and give thanks for his provision without overstepping and adding to his word? In other words, is “The Lord Will Provide” biblical, and will it worship?

Focus

“The Lord Will Provide” (as the title might suggest) is about God’s generosity in providing for our needs. It calls us to seek God’s kingdom and trust him to care for us rather than worrying about getting what we want or need.

This song freely floats between singing to God and singing to one another. It’s mostly personal, using me/my language to describe the relationship between the individual and the Lord, only acknowledging “us” once in the bridge. God is often addressed as You, and we call him God, our Father, and the Lord.

Lyric Analysis

VERSES
Verse 1 says “I don’t have to wonder; I know what You’re doing.” What he’s doing, in this song and in Scripture, is providing for our spiritual and physical needs.

The verses refer to Jesus’ words in Matthew 6:26-34. He invites his followers to consider the birds of the air and the lilies of the field. The birds don’t save up for winter or retirement, and the flowers don’t know how to sew. If our heavenly Father feeds and clothes them, then we can certainly trust him to take care of us!

One aspect of this story I’ve never considered before is that Jesus chooses living things which have relatively short lifespans for this example. It’s easy to watch a flower sprout, bloom, and fade all in a season. Sparrows (Mt 10:29-30) only live for 2-5 years. God cares for these creatures, but that doesn’t mean they last forever or face no hardship. Indeed, Jesus’ acknowledges our own mortality when he says, “And which of you by being anxious can add a single hour to his span of life?” (Mt 6:27)

PRE-CHORUSES
Each pre-chorus provides a little opportunity to respond in trust to God’s provision. Instead of worrying, we can look to God’s faithfulness. Instead of chasing more, more, and more, we can recognize that God’s love is what really satisfies us. He doesn’t just provide us with enough; he is enough.

A note about anxiety: Jesus gives firm but gentle correction in v. 34 when he calls the worrier “you of little faith.” When someone is in the pit of anxiety, these words can feel like a harsh rebuke, a command to do better, quit worrying, and just have faith! I have a couple thoughts that I hope will help. First, in vv. 31-32, Jesus defines worrying as behaving like godless Gentiles, constantly pursuing their own food and clothing rather than trusting that our Father knows what we need. Second, the solution isn’t just to have more willpower and stop feeling anxious. The way Jesus tells us to combat anxiety is by seeking his Kingdom. That can mean a lot of different things, but all of them involve focusing a little less on ourselves and a little more on other people. I won’t try to fully explore what seeking the Kingdom means here, but a great place to start is the wider Sermon on the Mount, of which this teaching on worry is but a small part. So Jesus doesn’t just tell us to stop being anxious, he gives us a picture of the kind of Kingdom life that will help us entrust our worries to him (1 Pt 5:7).

CHORUS
The chorus is short, sweet, and repetitious. God our Father has all we need, and we can trust him to provide it for us. Another meaning of “my Father has it” could be in the sense of “God’s got this.” If there’s a situation that seems out of control, these lyrics are a reminder that he’s still in control.

These words could certainly be misapplied. I need $50,000 to pay off my student loans. I need my estranged daughter to forgive me. I need policies to change so my family won’t be deported. I need a cure for this disease I’ve just been diagnosed with. These are all legitimate needs, and doesn’t the Bible say, “ask, and it will be given to you?” (Mt 7:7) This is, of course, one of the oldest questions in the world. If God is powerful and cares about me, why doesn’t he give me what I ask for in prayer? To be sure, sometimes, he does! Sometimes the disease is healed and the finances are provided. If we ask God continually for our daily bread, we find that he continually provides it, and that’s part of what this song is about. But what about when he doesn’t? In those instances, I think Jesus directs away from the God-has-to-give-me-what-I-ask-for mentality and toward trust. The answer isn’t that God doesn’t care, or that I sinned so he won’t hear me, or that I don’t have enough faith. If we look at the next few verses in Matthew 7, Jesus says, “If you then, who are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father who is in heaven give good things to those who ask him!” And in our main text for this song, he says, “your heavenly Father knows you need them.” We have a God who knows us, and he knows our needs. Even when it doesn’t seem like he’s coming through, he still cares for us and provides for us, and he still has good in store for us.

BRIDGE
We already alluded to this idea: seeking God’s Kingdom is the antidote to anxiety over our own needs. Being focused on loving others and trusting in the generosity of the Father will help us not to be wrapped up in what we think we need. His blessings often look different than we thought they would.

Accessibility

Trusting in God to provide for our needs can go wrong when we fall into two big errors: 1) thinking that he has to give us what we ask for and 2) thinking that when he doesn’t, it’s because he failed or we didn’t have enough faith. Expecting God to always come through the way we think he should is setting ourselves up for disappointment.

“The Lord Will Provide” could be misunderstood in this way, but it offers two correctives. First, the Pre-chorus 2 says that God is enough, and his love will satisfy us. I wish this truth were repeated more throughout the song. Second, it takes our eyes off of our anxiety for our present needs and sets them on God’s Kingdom.

One of the strongest lines in the song is also the most confusing. We’re supposed to seek the Kingdom and its treasures, but what does that mean? I don’t think most people in church really know, and this song doesn’t explain it.

The range of this song is all within an octave! And most of it falls within a 5th! Incredible! The repetitive melodic and rhythmic patterns make it extremely singable and easy to learn. All the bonus points!

Music

“The Lord Will Provide” is in 6/8 with a little bit of swing. It almost forces you to nod your head or sway a little bit. This rhythm draws you in and evokes a sense of steadiness and trust, a perfect match to the lyrics. When the singing starts, the melody paints the same picture. The chorus is insistent with its refrain “my Father has it.” The bridge drives forward, propelling the worshiper forward to seek God’s Kingdom.

This song relies on piano, drums, and bass, adding guitars throughout for more energy. For the most part, I don’t anticipate it being too difficult for beginner/intermediate musicians to play. The drum beat on the bridge is a little offbeat, so it might take some extra practice. The bass guitar does some really cool grooves, but these are not critical and can be omitted as skill requires. The piano lead line at the beginning shouldn’t be hard, but for some reason, it really tripped me up! I especially like having a soprano double the melody for extra power on the bridges.

Function

Gathering | Word | Table | Sending

“The Lord Will Provide” is most appropriate in the second half of the service. After the Word has been presented, the congregation has the opportunity to respond in trust. The challenge to “seek first the Kingdom” also gives this song a missional thrust appropriate to the Sending.

This song would be especially meaningful paired with a reading of Matthew 6:26-34 or 10:28-30. It would make an excellent response song to any teaching about anxiety, trusting God, his provision, or seeking the Kingdom. We’re introducing it right now during a teaching series on money and possessions, and I think it’s a great thematic fit.

It would be cool to see a worship service composed entirely of the Sermon on the Mount and various songs that express and respond to the ideas there. This song would be one of them.

Conclusions

Will it worship? Every single time! (sorry šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø)

I mentioned my concern about assuming God is going to answer all our prayers exactly how we want, the false promise of the prosperity Gospel. But I think “The Lord Will Provide” combats that misunderstanding effectively. It bases its lyrics heavily on Scripture and says what the Bible says without going a step further. It’s hard to argue with that!

We’re singing “The Lord Will Provide” this Sunday, and I’m confident the congregation will be grab onto it quickly to sing their trust and hope in God and his provision.

Image by CĆ©dric VT on Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

Is ‘Made For More’ Biblical? A Worship Song Analysis

/ Jason Henry / 1 Comment

I listened to “Made For More” a couple times earlier this year, and I liked it alright, but it didn’t really grab my attention until we sang it at ICYC this weekend. I grew up attending this conference, so it was a neat full-circle moment to be able to come back and play keys in the worship band. Looking out over the students and singing this song, I found myself moved to prayer for them, that they would see that God has made them for more and that they would be raised to new life and new purpose in Jesus.

Josh Baldwin released “Made For More” as a live single featuring Jenn Johnson in January of this year. It has continued to grow in popularity since then, being featured on a single and album from Bethel and accruing over 8,000,000 Spotify streams in its various forms as of November 2024. Baldwin is a songwriter on the track, along with Blake Wiggins, Jessie Early (Nothing Else), and Jonathan Smith (House of the Lord, Glorious Day, Manger Throne).

You and I might be made for more, but is “Made For More” made for worship? Let’s dig in and see if “Made For More” is biblical and if it belongs on your Sunday setlist.

Focus

“Made For More” is about our identity, calling, and purpose, all found in Christ’s death and resurrection. It is both an encouragement and a call to action.

There is a lot of “I” and “my” in this song. I don’t think “Made For More” is self-centered, but it is individualistic. I’ll address both of those below.

We sing this song to God and address him as “You.” The reference to the “cross of salvation” makes it clear that we’re singing to the Christian God, not just any random deity.

Lyric Analysis

VERSE
The first line is the thesis of the whole song; “I know who I am cause I know who You are.” As believers, our identity is in Jesus. Paul teaches in 2 Corinthians 5:17, “if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old has passed away; behold, the new has come,” and again in Galatians 2:20, “I have been crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me.” When we become Christians, we join Jesus in his death on the cross and are raised with him to new life. Christ identifies so closely with his church that we are called his body and his dwelling place (Eph 1:22-23, 2:22).

This verse declines to look back to our lost state before the cross, instead focusing on who we are now: chosen (1 Pet 2:9), free (Jn 8:36), forgiven (Ac 10:43), having a future worth living (Jer 29:11). This future is both now and not yet. Yes, we have a glorious eternity to look forward to in the new heaven and new earth that are to come (Rev 21:1-4), but we are also Jesus’ emissaries, witnesses that Christ has come to reconcile the world and that his kingdom is already here! Empowered by his Spirit, we carry this reconciliation with us and provide a foretaste to the world and the whole creation of what the glory of God’s fully realized kingdom will be like (Ac 1:8, 2 Cor 5:18-19, Rom 8:19-23).

CHORUS
In the first two lines of the chorus, I think the songwriters must have been thinking of Luke 9:57-62. Three different people are called to follow Jesus but present various excuses, one of them saying, “let me first go and bury my father.” Jesus replies, “Leave the dead to bury their own dead. But as for you, go and proclaim the kingdom of God.” I don’t know the ins and outs of Jewish funeral customs, and someone else could certainly explain this story better than I, but it seems clear that all three people in this passage are looking back at their old life, finding excuses to remain trapped in the past rather than following Jesus into the new life of his kingdom.

Again, when we follow Jesus, we are baptized into his death and raised to new life with him. We can’t walk in our old, dead ways anymore because we have been born again (Rom 6:2-4).

The verse says this in yet a third way: instead of lying in a bed of shame, we have the opportunity to embrace the fountain of forgiveness, holiness, and grace that flows from Jesus (Zech 13:1). This grace not only give us life, but overflows from us to give life to others (Jn 7:38).

One thing that catches my attention in the chorus is that all the statements about “me” are in the passive voice. (šŸ¤“) Instead of “You made me for more,” it’s “I was made for more.” Is Josh trying to take God out of the picture? Why put the emphasis on me instead of God?? In fact, that’s the opposite of what’s going on here. The rhythm and melody place the emphasis on the third syllable of the line, so if we rephrase this line to make God the subject, then the word “me” actual falls on the third syllable and gets the emphasis. “You made me for more.” The way the song is written, it’s “I was made for more,” so the musical emphasis is on God’s act of making. The same is true of “I was called by name.”

BRIDGE
“Hallelujah” is a Hebrew word combining hallel, praise, with Jah, a shortened form of the name of God. It literally means “praise Yahweh.”

Jesus makes a habit of calling his followers by name. Mary, Peter, Zacchaeus, and even Paul/Saul experience the direct, personal attention of the Savior when he says their names. This interaction is transformative, totally changing the direction of their lives. To be called by name is to be known, and God certainly knows us deeply and fully (Psalm 139:1-16). When he brings us into his kingdom, we are not anonymous servants, but we are his children, heirs, and friends (Jn 15:15, Rom 8:17).

How can we respond to this love, this knowing, and this calling but with praise? And having died to sin and been resurrected with Christ, how can we turn back and live in sin and the shame of our past? (Rom 6:2)

Accessibility

Even without knowledge of the Scriptures referenced in the song, the powerful word pictures in “Made For More” invite the worshiper into the new identity, new life, and new purpose of the children of God.

I have two concerns regarding understanding. First, this song is pretty vague about what we were made for. More, yes, but more of what? We get some suggestive words like life, future, grace, praise, and Yours, and together, they sketch an outline of what new life in Christ feels like, but without an understanding of our purpose and mission from Scripture, we can fill that outline in with any dream or aspiration we like. Made for more…money? Nope.

Second, the language in this song is very individualistic. Our individual relationships with God are important, and we are each of us known and called personally, but our calling as a community, as the church is at least equally important. This isn’t necessarily a weakness, I just want to make sure that we aren’t only singing songs about our individual lives; we also need songs that discuss our calling, purpose, and identity as the unified Bride of Christ.

The majority of the melody is within a sixth. When you include the octave jump from the first verse and chorus to the second, the total range is an octave plus a third, so not bad for a contemporary worship song. Rhythmically, the chorus is especially easy to pick up on because of the way the words pulse easily with the beat.

Music

“Made For More” begins with simple piano chords accompanying the voices through the first verse. The rest of the band enters quietly at the first chorus, playing single chords that have the effect of unity and confidence. We jump up to a higher dynamic level for the second verse, now celebrating the words that we sang in quiet faith the first time. What was an expression of hope in the first chorus is now fully claimed as the truth of who we are. We drop back down for a slow build through the bridges which lead to a dramatic dropout for a chorus, really highlighting the voice of the congregation. There’s another loud chorus, then a loud bridge, then a quiet closing chorus. These are pretty standard dynamics for a worship song, but they are standard for a reason, and they communicate this song’s message well.

The only tricky chords are halfway through the post-bridge chorus when the band comes in. There’s a walkdown there that sounds best if it’s played with open 5ths rather than full chords. The rest of the song makes use of frequent alternate bass notes and suspended chords so that it feels a little more interesting than a I, IV, vi, V song.

I would call this an easy-intermediate song for a worship band to play.

Conclusions

“Made For More” is catchy, inviting, easy to learn, and easy to understand. It is both an encouragement to the downcast and a call-to-action for believers. As we sing, God reminds us that we are his dearly loved children, and his Spirit calls us out on mission. If we are made for more, we must take seriously the words and deeds that Christ calls us to; we must be the foretaste of his coming kingdom in this broken world.

I outlined above my two concerns above in the Accessibility section: this song is a little vague about what we are made for, leaving room to import wrong ideas, and it is very individualistic. Neither of these is an error, and no song can fully explain every subject that it touches on. We need to make sure that our song libraries contain more specific calls to share the Gospel, care for the poor, sick, and elderly, and be good news to our friends, neighbors, communities, and the whole world. We also need to make sure we have songs that sing about us and Jesus instead of only me and Jesus.

Having said all that, I think “Made For More” fills an important niche in our church song catalog. The vagueness that I mentioned as a concern is also a strength, allowing it to serve as a sending song connected to any number of scriptural calls to action. It provides encouragement and exhortation without assuming anyone’s emotional state or life story, and it reminds all of us that we have new life in Christ, and that it’s worth living that way.

Will it worship? You betcha.

Image by Courtney Cook on Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

THAT’S WHO I PRAISE – Brandon Lake

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment

This is a fun one! The latest in a long line of Brandon Lake hits with “Praise” in the title, “That’s Who I Praise” is a joyful, upbeat song of trust and praise. It came out this summer, and it’s already at the top of Brandon’s Spotify list, outranking Gratitude, Graves into Gardens, and Praise You Anywhere. The product of a collaboration between Benjamin Hastings, Brandon Lake, Micah Nichols, Steven Furtick, and Zac Lawson, “That’s Who I Praise” has a lot to say, so if I can pull myself out of the drum groove for a minute, we’ll check out the lyrics and find out if it’s biblical and if it will worship!

Focus

This song has two major themes. The chorus and bridge describe the character and power of Jesus. The verses invite us into the many ways his people respond to him in praise.

“That’s Who I Praise” uses many biblical titles and names for Jesus as well as some new ones. It identifies Jesus as God, and it’s abundantly clear that’s who we’re praising and singing about.

There’s a lot of “I” in this song. The authors use the phrase “I want” 10 times, and say things like “God’s got my back.” So the individual worshiper is also a focus of this song. Does this make “That’s Who I Praise” a self-centered worship song? That depends on how all those “I”s are used!

Lyric Analysis

VERSE 1
In the verses, the authors show various responses of praise and trust throughout Scripture and express their wish to respond the same way.

David danced before the ark of the Lord, celebrating God with all his might even though it was undignified (2 Sam 6:14). We want to have that same attitude, praising God without regard for our personal appearance or what others might think.

Paul and Silas sang hymns to God in prison, and then God freed them with an earthquake (Ac 16:25-26). Their song freed them and their fellow prisoners from the physical chains. But the real miracle is what happens next: rather than fleeing the prison, Paul and Silas stay to tell their jailer about Christ. He and his whole family are baptized, free from the chains of sin and death (Ac 16:27-34). We want to have that kind of faith!

Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego were thrown into a fiery furnace as a death sentence for refusing to worship an idol. Rather than burning up, they were unharmed by the flames, and a fourth figure appeared in the furnace walking around with them. People disagree on whether the fourth figure should be identified as an angel or perhaps Christ himself, but it’s clear that God was with them and protected them as they insisted that only the one true God was worthy of worship. When we also refuse to worship idols (literal or metaphorical) but turn our praise to the one true God, we can trust that he will be with us and will protect us.

VERSE 2
Moses and the Israelites crossed through the Red Sea on dry land when God parted the waters to allow them escape from Egypt. This formative event freed them from slavery and established their identity as a people (Ex 14). Like Moses, we want to trust in God and obey his commands even when they don’t make sense, and like the Israelites, we trust him to lead us into his eternal Kingdom.

There are all kinds of things in this life that frighten us, but God is greater than all of them, and nothing in all Creation can separate us from his love (Rom 8:38-39). Furthermore, in Philippians 1:27-30, Paul envisions a church whose unity and faith in the Gospel allows them to face opposition, suffering, and fear, confident that even these things point to their salvation in Christ.

VERSE 3
There are lots of Marys in the Bible, and this song refers to Mary of Bethany. She’s the sister of Lazarus (who Jesus raised from the dead) and Martha (who Jesus encouraged to do less housework.) In John 12, Mary pours a pound of expensive perfume over Jesus’ feet, then dries them with her hair. The parallel account in Mark 14 tells us that the perfume was in an alabaster flask (or vase), and that she broke it open in order to pour it out to the Lord. This ointment and its container were a serious investment, and Mary devotes the whole thing to Jesus. Once the flask is broken, there’s no putting the ointment back inside. We want to be similarly devoted with our hearts, our lives, and our resources.

Daniel (like his friends Rack, Shack, and Benny, mentioned above) ran afoul of a law forbidding him to faithfully worship Yahweh. When he refused to stop praying to God three times a day, he was condemned to spend a night sealed in a den of lions (Daniel 6). The text doesn’t tell us whether he slept or not, but when the king and his officials returned the next morning, Daniel was unharmed. In this part of the song, we’re asking for the peace to trust God and not fear the scheming of men (Pr 29:25).

Shortly after Israel began to enter the Promised Land, the city of Jericho stood in the way. God told Joshua, “See, I have given over Jericho into your hand,” and then gave him instructions that the people should march around the walls for six days, and then on the seventh to march around it seven times and blow the trumpets. They obeyed, and the walls fell. This song applies these words to our spiritual lives. Our praise is the figurative (or literal; I don’t know what your church is like šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø) trumpet blast that brings down any wall that comes between us and our Promised Land. For the Christian, this is not a literal land or physical possession, but our relationship with Christ is our inheritance (Ps 16:5-6). Nothing in this world or the next can separate us from his love, so anything that tries must come tumblin’ down (Rom 8:31-39).

CHORUS
The repeated line “I’m gonna praise” is reminiscent of the Psalmist’s “Bless/praise the Lord, O my soul!” (Ps 103:1, 146:1). In both, we remind our hearts that God is worthy of our worship and we exhort ourselves (and our fellow believers) to worship. Next, the song gives us several reasons God is worthy of our worship.

He moves mountains in response to the faithful prayers of his people (Mt 17:20).

He raised Christ bodily from the dead, freeing us from the chains of death and promising us new life on earth and eternal, resurrected life after we die (1 Cor 15:20, Rom 6:4).

Jesus is seated in the heavenly places with the Father (Col 3:1). This is a place of honor, and a place of ruling over creation.

Even in giving himself up to die, Jesus won the victory over death, defeating the last enemy of God and creation (1 Cor 15:26, 54-56, Col 2:13-15). Because of this stunning act of humility and sacrifice, the name of Jesus is the highest name in all heaven and earth (Ph 2:4-11).

Nothing is impossible with God (Mt 19:26).

BRIDGE
Jesus is the conquering Lion from the tribe of Judah who comes to enact God’s final judgment against sin (Rev 5:5). Then, in the very next verse, when he appears, it is not as a lion but as the holy and slain Lamb (Rev 5:6). He has conquered sin and death by taking their consequences and uncleanness upon himself and making mankind and creation holy through his blood. For this, he is counted worthy (Rev 5:9).

Jesus is the Messiah, the Christ, God’s Anointed One, crucified and raised to life (Ac 2:36).

The Ancient of Days is a title for God in the apocalyptic vision found in Daniel 7. In this vision, the Ancient of Days receives the Son of Man (Jesus’ favorite title for himself) and gives him dominion, glory, and a kingdom. At first glance, it is a little odd that we’re singing to Jesus but using a title for God the Father, but John uses this same depiction of the Ancient of Days to describe Christ in Revelation 1. Both have eyes of fire, hair like pure wool, and shining clothes. So I think it’s best to remember Jesus’ statement that “I and the Father are one” (Jn 10:30) and not stress too much about which Person of the Trinity we’re addressing.

Accessibility

The verses require a great deal of Bible background knowledge to understand. I think someone without much church background would likely understand that we’re expressing a desire to emulate Bible heroes and their faith. They would recognize some images like Moses parting the Red Sea. But this represents a real barrier to understanding. Similarly, the chorus throws a bunch of descriptors out real fast without stopping to explain, so they could easily fly over many people’s heads. At the same time, this song presents a sliding scale of understanding, and it will make more sense the more that someone understands about God’s story. Hearing unfamiliar names and references might encourage people to dig in and learn what stories this song is talking about.

Without understanding the Bible stories referenced in the song, it’s possible to come away with just meaningless positivity. “God’s got my back!” “I’m gonna get that promise!” These statements can lead to complacency and laziness without understanding their context. God told the Israelites to march around Jericho, because he had decreed that it would fall. God protected Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego in the fire because they chose to honor his name instead of bowing to a false god. These are not blanket promises that God is going to destroy every “Jericho” I see in my life or that he supports my every decision. God is worthy of our praise and our obedience.

The chorus has a little bit of the same problem, but it’s not as bad since the words are generalized and don’t include “me” and “my.” Just because he is a mountain mover doesn’t mean that the problem I’ve identified as a mountain is going to be dealt with the way I want it to.

This one is pretty rangy. The song stretches an octave plus a sixth, so almost 2 octaves. This isn’t too out of the norm for a worship song, but we should expect that the lows are going to be too low or the highs too high for most congregants. (Or both! šŸ˜¬) There are also several tongue twister moments in this one where most people will struggle to spit all the words out. I can already hear the congregation singing “I’m gonna praise! I’m gonna praise! I’m gonna humanumahumanuma highest of names!”

On the whole, I have to admit that congregational accessibility is a weakness of this song.

Music

“That’s Who I Praise” is super dynamic and energetic. It’s very much a CCM radio-friendly song; the sudden changes in intensity between parts of the song are great for captivating and holding short attention spans. They also make the song really fun to play! If you’re working on this one with a band, I would spend some extra time nailing those down so that everybody is in sync, especially the three hits at the beginning of each chorus (They’re dotted eighths, not triplets!).

Nothing too surprising in the chord progression, but CCLI SongSelect gets a couple of the chords wrong in the chord chart. There should be Cm instead of Eb on the first line of Verse 2 and Verse 3 (Thanks Robby Sams for catching that one!).

As I mentioned above, the melody line covers a wide range and is tricky to sing. So you’ll want to spend some time picking the right key and making sure your vocalist is up to leading this one. Fortunately, the parts for the instruments are simpler, so I think this song would be appropriate for an intermediate-level volunteer band.

Conclusions

Pros: The music is awesome and doable for the average church worship band. The words exalt Jesus for his resurrection and our salvation and hearken back to the praise responses of lots of Bible characters.

Cons: Difficult to learn and sing. Could be a little clearer about what kind of mountains God moves, though the Bible references do clear that up with a little digging. I wish it were a little more “we,” a little less “I.”

Will it worship? I am excited to sing “That’s Who I Praise” this Sunday, but if I’m really honest, I’ve got to call it a “Maybe.” The melody just isn’t very congregation-friendly. It’s a super fun, upbeat celebration of Christ’s power and worth, but it’s going to take several weeks (or a lot of K-Love listening) for the people to be able to sing along.

Image by Thomas Park on Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

MANGER THRONE – Phil Wickham

/ Jason Henry / 3 Comments

“Manger Throne” is a new Christmas worship anthem from songwriters Phil Wickham, Jonathan Smith, and Tony Wood. The lyrics juxtapose Christ’s glory with his humility, his throne with his manger. The music paints those words with epic, sweeping accompaniment that feels like a return to the soundscapes I loved on 2010’s Heaven & Earth.

“Manger Throne” got lots of radio play in the 2023 holiday season, but is it a worship song? Are the words theologically sound and biblically accurate? What even is a manger throne? Do you sit on it or in it? And does Jesus still have one? Let’s find out!

Focus

The main idea of this song is the humility of Christ’s Incarnation. Phil explores this theme through the paradoxical image of a manger throne and by exploring the connection between the Christmas story and the story of Christ’s death and resurrection.

This song is fully Christ-centered. It is all about the person and work of Jesus, calling him by name and exalting him for his victory-through-humility.

Lyric Analysis

VERSES
(WARNING: I’m going to jump around a little bit to unpack this song thematically rather than in order. If that stresses you out, I apologize.)

The two verses of this song portray the same idea. Jesus had all power and authority at his disposal when he entered into our world, but he chose to come meekly, humbly, fully embracing our humanity by being born as a baby.

Jesus could have come into the world with a pillar of fire as in the Exodus (Ex 13:22) or perhaps the consuming fire that destroyed the blaspheming priests Nadab and Abihu (Lev 10:1-3). The same heavenly host that came to sing a song of peace at Christ’s birth might well have brought a sword instead (Lk 2:12-14, Gen 3:24). Jesus could have come as a conqueror to overthrow the oppressive yoke of Rome, force the submission of all the nations, and establish Israel’s political ascendancy as many expected him to do during his earthly ministry (Ac 1:6-7).

But, as verse two says, the story God wrote through the Incarnation is so much better! Rather than conquer through overwhelming force, Jesus humbles himself, emptying himself of his divine power. He becomes fully human, allowing himself to be embraced by common, lowly peopleā€”a carpenter, his wife, some shepherdsā€”so that he might fully embrace all of our humanity (Phil 2:6-8).

PRE-CHORUS 1
“But You chose meekness over majesty//wrapped Your power in humanity”

These two lines are a perfect summary of the verses. It’s a succinct expression of Christ emptying himself to take on the form of a servant (Phil 2:6-8, again).

PRE-CHORUS 2
This section identifies the culmination of Christ’s humility. As we read in Philippians 2:8 (for the third time), Jesus’s humility did not merely extend to being born as a man. He submitted himself even to a humiliating, torturous death for our sake. Jesus’ blood redeems us to God and forgives our sins (Eph 1:7). And his resurrection is the power and the guarantee of our resurrection with him (Rom 6:5). I appreciate that this bridge views Christ’s work through the lenses of substitutionary atonement and his victory over sin and death.

BRIDGE
Here, we see the full arc of the Incarnation. Jesus was enthroned in heaven from eternity past, and then he willingly humbled himself to be born in a stable, cradled in a feeding trough. From the beginning of his life on earth, he lived humbly, and he did not refuse to submit to death on the cross. If we read just two more verses from Philippians 2, we see the result of all of Christ’s humility and submission: exaltation.

“Therefore God has highly exalted him and bestowed on him the name that is above every name, so that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth“
Philippians 2:9-10

Jesus’ reign and glory are achieved through self-sacrifice, humility, peace, and bringing all of humanity together in himself (Eph 2:14), not through violence, political maneuvering, manipulation, or any other scheme of man that has supported every other throne in human history.

CHORUS
“Glory be to You alone//King who reigns from a manger throne”

God alone is holy, worthy of worship, his name glorified forever (Rev 15:4). Jesus is both God and King (Heb 1:8, Phil 2:9-10), so it is right and good to offer him this glory.

It is also good to offer him our lives and our possessions, as we are called to be living sacrifices (Rom 12:1). This line is an expression of surrender. It’s aspirational in a sense, because I don’t know anyone whose life and possessions are fully surrendered to Jesus, but that doesn’t make it untrue. In singing this line, we call ourselves and one another to be more wholly devoted to our Servant King and his Kingdom of servants.

But what about the titular Manger Throne? Are we saying that Jesus was actively reigning over his kingdom from the manger even while he was a pre-verbal infant? That doesn’t quite make sense if he emptied himself and took the position of a servant (Phil 2:7). Or are we talking about Jesus’ present reign at the right hand of God? Does that throne need to be manger-shaped? Or maybe it’s made of reclaimed wood from the manger? Or maybe this is the future millennial reign?

Fortunately, we don’t need to tie ourselves into such knots over this song. The manger throne is a visual illustration of Jesus’ character and a symbol of his reign and kingdom, not a literal piece of furniture. Getting hung up on whether Jesus could be said to “reign” as an infant misses the point of the song because we’re not talking to tiny baby Jesus; we’re talking to the resurrected King Jesus who is present with us today as we worship him. This Jesus is fully God and sits enthroned, and he is also fully human, still characterized by the love and humility that led him to be born in a manger.

(Thank you to Vince and Neal on The Berean Test for some stimulating thoughts on this section of the song, and the image of the manger throne in particular!)

Accessibility

This song uses plain language to express the deep mystery of Jesus’ glory and humility, his Godhood and his humanity, perfectly one in the incarnate Son. It does a great job of making these heady theological ideas accessible through description and imagery, especially the key metaphor of the manger throne. I don’t see any room for misinterpretation.

Singability is ok, not great, not terrible. The range is an octave plus a 3rd, not bad. The rhythms of the verses are a little tricky, especially since no line starts quite the same way. The bridge also has a different melody on the repeat, so the congregation doesn’t have an opportunity to learn it and then repeat it the same way. That said, the chorus is very straightforward. It’s got a high note, but it can be sung an octave lower by the basses in the room.

Music

As I mentioned above, I love how this song feels like classic Phil Wickham. The use of synth and choir is lush, beautiful, and impactful. If you have those tools at your disposal, use them! I also appreciate that even though this is a Christmas song, it doesn’t slap you in the face with holiday cheer. It’s not all sleigh bells and minor 7ths and snow and reindeer. This song is perfectly appropriate to any Sunday of the year, especially if Christ’s incarnation is being discussed. We just played it this past Sunday, in June, and nobody batted an eye. (…but we did have to swap out some of the glittery Christmas backgrounds in ProPresenter!)

This is a great song for teaching dynamics to a worship band. It follows the typical structure of a quiet opening building to some bigger choruses and a huge ending. The way the instruments layer in gradually through the song is easy to replicate and makes this song flow naturally and in an engaging way. (Just don’t let anybody play when they’re not supposed to!) The chord changes come pretty quick in a few places, so it might be worth it to work through those together once or twice in rehearsal. If your lead singer isn’t a tenor, you may need to bump it down a step, and they will want to practice the entrances on the verses; those are tricky.

Conclusions

Let heaven and nature sing! “Manger Throne” definitely worships. It links Christ’s birth to his death, resurrection, and eternal reign. It teaches the theology of the Incarnation in a unique and valuable way through imagery. It’s also beautiful, emotional, and fun to sing and play.

10/10 would recommend!

Image by Pro Church Media on Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

A THOUSAND SHORES – Citizens

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment

“A Thousand Shores” (not Hallelujahs, Names, Tongues or Reasons. For real, I’m starting to get all of these “thousand” songs mixed up. šŸ˜‚) is written by Leeland Mooring, Leslie Jordan, and Zachary Bolen. It ‘s part of Citizens’ 2023 album I Can’t Find the Edges of You, the home of certified banger “Good Ground,” which I love and have reviewed already.

While “Good Ground” and “Everything and More” were my initial favorites from this release, “A Thousand Shores” grew on me every time I heard it, and some of my fellow worship leaders agreed, so we introduced it at Christ’s Church a couple weeks ago. The band has really enjoyed it, and the congregation has grabbed ahold of it as well, but is “A Thousand Shores” biblical, and will it worship? Let’s figure out what we’ve been singing!

Focus

This song expresses the wonder and joy of being known by Jesus and filled with his life-sustaining love. The most repeated line and heartbeat of the song is “Jesus, You are my everything,” an expression of devotion to Jesus and a statement of his all-sufficiency.

This song is about the closeness of Jesus to the believer, so there’s lots of “my” in the song, and also lots of “You” referring to Jesus. Jesus is the only member of the Trinity mentioned specifically.

Lyric Analysis

VERSES 1 & 2
These verses express wonder at how deeply Jesus knows us and at the sovereign way he works in our lives. The author says God can read our hearts like a book, a sentiment the Eleven Disciples share in Acts 1:24, and that he knows what is in our minds before we ask it, an important principle Jesus teaches along with the Lord’s Prayer (Matt 6:8).

When this song says, “You write my story and call it good,” I think it’s paraphrasing Romans 8:28, which says “for those who love God, all things work together for good.” God is the author of our faith journey (Heb 12:2), and we can trust that his plans are good even as we are unable to imagine or comprehend his ways (Job 9:10, Isa 55:8). The phrase “You’re in my future, You’re in my past” reminds me of Psalm 139:13-16, where David praises God for knowing him and every one of his days even before he was formed in the womb.

As a response to this God’s wondrous knowledge of our inmost being and his unsearchable plans, we cry out with Moses, “Who is like you, majestic in holiness, awesome in glorious deeds, doing wonders?” (Ex 15:11).

CHORUS
“You give my lungs the air to breathe // You are my everything”

In the chorus, we praise Jesus for things that he gives us. We’re not really talking about material blessings here; we’re more describing the experience of knowing Christ and walking with him. He gives light to our eyes (Pro 29:11), words to our lips (Matt 10:19), and breath to our lungs (Gen 2:7) as well putting a song in our soul (Zeph 3:17) and giving us every beat of our hearts. Jesus doesn’t just give us life when we’re born or when we become Christians, he sustains us by his power every moment, and the whole universe only holds together because of his active involvement (Col 1:17). “In him, we live and move and have our being.” (Ac 17:28) This is what we mean when we say, “You are my everything.”

I think it’s important to note that calling Jesus our everything does not dishonor the other Persons of the Trinity, devalue the community of the church, or denigrate our bodily and emotional needs. Regarding the Trinity, all of God fully receives all worship offered to Jesus. He is creator, sustainer, the head of the church, the beginning and the end, given preeminence in all things. The fullness of God is pleased to dwell in him (Col 1:15-20). The Father and Spirit are never threatened by honor given to Jesus but are fully included in it. The church is the very body of Christ, the fulness of his presence, the earthly epicenter of his all-in-all-ness (Eph 1:22-23). So participating in Christian community is part of what it means to have Jesus as our everything. Regarding physical needs, Christ promises that his Father provides for them when we seek after him (Matt 6:32-33). Trusting in Jesus as our everything means subordinating all those needs because we know that we need him more.

VERSE 3
This short verse is about the immensity and infinity of Jesus’ love. Much like the uncountable grains of sand on a thousand shores, the love of Christ can never run out. It is eternal, abounding, steadfast, forgiving, and perfect (1 Jn 4:18, John 3:16, Ps 136:26). I can’t imagine a greater truth than that either!

BRIDGE
The phrase “too wonderful” appears in the Bible when the speaker acknowledges that he can’t comprehend God’s power and wisdom and love. Job says this of God’s tremendous power in creating and sustaining the world, and of the way God has been active even through Job’s suffering (Job 42:3). David says it when praising God for how deeply and perfectly God knows each one of us (Ps 139:6). It conveys an inability to understand, but also a deep awe, reverence, and amazement.

If you are in Christ, you never have to worry about what life or eternity would be like without Jesus, because nothing can ever separate you from his love or rip you out of his hand (John 17:11-12, Rom 8:39). I’m not going to get into the once-saved-always-saved debate here; suffice it to say that the Bible warns us against falling away from Christ, but it also reassures us that nothing short of a full rejection of the Son of God can ever sever our relationship with him (Heb 6:4-6, 2 Tim 2:12-13).

Accessibility

While God’s ways and his love are incomprehensible, “A Thousand Shores” is not. It uses easy-to-understand language to describe and celebrate beautiful, biblical truths about God and his relationship to us. You don’t need a theology degree or a lifetime of accumulated Sunday school lessons to understand this one. šŸ‘šŸ‘

I don’t see any danger of serious misunderstandings in this song. Some church people might think the song excludes the Father and Holy Spirit, or that it takes a particular stance on eternal security, but that’s just not the case, as I discussed above.

This song is highly congregational, as long as your congregation isn’t scared of a little syncopation! The melodies are highly repetitive, making them easy to learn, and the range is only a sixth! That’s super rare in contemporary worship songs and it means that just about anyone can find a comfortable place to sing this song whatever key you put it in.

Music

Simple, repetitive chord changes. Repetitive melody. Nothing insane going on rhythmically. The basic drum pattern of kick and snare is easy to grab onto. There’s lots of synth in this one, so I like to use a track for those arpeggiators and atmospheric effects. The only real challenge for the band is going to be the highly syncopated lyrics. It’s a little tricky to stay in time when the melody seems to avoid the beat.

The key to the dynamics of this song is contrast. The dramatic entrances and exits of different instruments, the octave jumps, the nearly yelled vocals on the bridge with almost no instrumentation, all of it makes this song exciting and easy to engage with.

I mentioned earlier that the range of this song is only a sixth. That’s not quite true for the lead vocalist. šŸ˜¬ There is an octave jump from verse 3 to the chorus, so that makes the range for the lead singer an octave plus a sixth. Yikes! Fortunately, this is easily fixed by just not singing the first part of the song an octave lower, or having a singer of the opposite sex sing that portion. I’ve found that if I include the octave jump, it is helpful to have another man continue singing the melody an octave lower to give the men in the congregation an anchor so they don’t have to jump up high with me.

Conclusions

Will it worship? Totally. “A Thousand Shores” revels in the mysteries of Jesus: his love, his deep knowing, his life-giving presence. It is an exuberant anthem of joy and devotion, and I plan to keep on singing it!

Image by Mitchell Shwartz on Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from theĀ ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

I SPEAK JESUS – Charity Gayle, Here Be Lions

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment

Few songs in recent memory have captured the power of living in Christ like “I Speak Jesus.” It is a declaration of victory, a commitment to persevere, and an anthem of faith in God. The most popular recording of “I Speak Jesus” is of Charity Gayle and Steven Musso, but it was originally released by Here Be Lions in 2019, and the songwriters behind this hit are Abby Benton, Carlene Prince, Dustin Smith, Jesse Reeves, Kristen Dutton, and Raina Pratt.

Something about this song really stirs up the heart toward faith, hope, and action, and as a new parent, the line “Jesus for my family” speaks to me in a way I can’t quite describe. But what does it actually mean to speak the name of Jesus? And what does it do? Is “I Speak Jesus” built on the promises of God’s Word, or empty assumptions? Should you sing it this Sunday? Let’s dig in and find out.

Focus

“I Speak Jesus” is about the power of Jesus’ name to transform our lives and our world. It describes the strengths of his name and situations that will be helped by his name.

This song (obviously) mentions Jesus’ name frequently. The verses seem to be sung to the congregation about Jesus and his name, while the choruses are addressed to Jesus and offer him praise and supplication.

Lyric Analysis

The meaning of this song hinges on one ambiguous phrase: “I speak Jesus.” What do we actually mean when we sing these words? I think these words can have several beneficial, healthy, scriptural meanings, and one unhealthy, dangerous meaning.

A REMINDER
Sometimes we speak Jesus’ name as a reminder to ourselves and others that he is with us. The lyrics of verse 1 talk about speaking his name over “every heart and every mind” because of the peace found in his presence (John 14:27). It is easy to forget that God himself is with us. It is easy to forget the hope that we have in Jesus’ death and resurrection. It is easy to seek temporary pleasure and security rather than his eternal Kingdom. Sometimes we just need to be reminded!

A WEAPON
Next, we see the name of Jesus as a weapon to fight spiritual battles. The songwriters portray his name as a breaker of addictions, chains, and strongholds. Paul talks about wielding spiritual weapons in this way in 2 Corinthians 10:3-8. The strongholds he mentions are arguments against God, thoughts that don’t honor Christ, and disobedience to Jesus. He fights these battles within his congregations in the authority Christ has given him, or in the name of Jesus. He also rebukes and casts out a demon in the name of Jesus Christ in Acts 16:18.

So we don’t just remind ourselves who Jesus is when we invoke his name, we also remind the powers of darkness that try to enslave and destroy us that Christ has already defeated them, and they must bow before his authority. It’s important to note that using Jesus’ name does not guarantee immediate victory in every spiritual battle. Paul himself struggled with a “thorn in his flesh” that God would not remove despite Paul’s pleading (2 Cor. 12:7-9). Sometimes, God wants to take the attacks of Satan and use them for good rather than prevent them, and we never see the full picture of the spiritual battles we face.

A PRAYER
Sometimes, when we talk about speaking Jesus’ name, we might just mean that we’re praying to him. That is absolutely an appropriate way to face every situation named in this song. The Bible instructs us to bring our requestsā€”especially those that cause us anxietyā€”to God in prayer (Phil. 4:6). Furthermore, James tells us that praying for one another is powerful and may bring healing (James 5:16).

We often close our prayers with the phrase, “in Jesus’ name, amen.” I suspect this habit reduces Jesus’ name to a stamp that we affix to the end of our prayers, preventing us from considering what it really means to pray or act in Jesus’ name. When I look at the various uses of “in my name” in the New Testament, I don’t get the impression that Jesus means we should simply slap his name onto the end of each prayer, and that that will make God answer it, as is sometimes misunderstood from passages like John 16:23. Rather, doing something in someone’s name means doing it on their behalf, in their authority, as instructed and permitted by that person. I think praying in Jesus’ name means joining the Son of God in the prayers he is already praying to the Father, echoing his promises, obeying his commands, being about his business, making his name known. Those are the kinds of requests God always grants.

A DECLARATION
In the previous section, I mentioned that part of praying and acting in Jesus’ name is making his name known. That’s part of what this song means too. When we speak Jesus’ name into all kinds of situations, we give God glory by trusting in him and thanking him for what he has already done. I think this is what the chorus means when it asks him to burn like a fire. We want his glory to shine forth from our lives and every circumstance.

We also declare our intent when we speak Jesus’ name over something or someone. For instance, when I speak Jesus over my family, I am declaring that I will bring his love, holiness, and influence into our home. If I declare Jesus over a sin struggle, I am surrendering it and expressing my intent to obey him rather than my deceitful desires (Eph. 4:21-23).

AN INVITATION
“I Speak Jesus” also has an evangelistic component. In exhorting one another to “shout Jesus from the mountains, Jesus in the streets,” we are encouraging the spread of the Gospel. We want to proclaim the good news of Christ’s death, resurrection, and coming Kingdom so loudly that everyone can hear it.

A MAGIC WORD
What the name of Jesus is not is a magic word. Physically speaking Jesus’ name is not a charm against misfortune or a guarantee that God will answer our prayers the way we want him to. Our temptations to sin, our addictions, our mental health struggles, and our life circumstances do not vanish when we speak the word “Jesus.” We do well to approach Jesus’ name humbly, bringing our requests to him with thanksgiving rather than insisting on our way or demanding things “in his name.”

My primary concern with this song is that there is a large segment of the Church that teaches that through a word of faith, believers can immediately claim their “right” to prosperity, healing, power, and victory. Since this song doesn’t explain what it means to speak the name of Jesus, it lends itself to this erroneous and harmful belief.

Accessibility

“I Speak Jesus” is eminently singable and congregational, especially the chorus. It’s easy to learn, and I find that congregations latch onto it almost immediately.

The words of this song are accessible but easily misapplied. This song focuses an awful lot on Jesus’ name, ascribing various characteristics to his name rather than himself. I don’t think this is necessarily an error, since a name is a representation of the thing itself, not a separate entity, but I do worry that it builds up the name of Jesus as a magic word that guarantees our success and answered prayers.

Music

The simple, almost plaintive first verses are a quiet expression of our need and God’s power. The instrumentation stays very sparse and the vocals are very restrained through the first chorus. Only in verse three do the kick and toms come in to accompany the crescendoing vocals. By chorus two, we hit our stride. We drop back down for the emotional intensity of the bridge which builds dramatically with driving snare and guitars to lead into another big chorus. The recording makes excellent use of antiphony here between the leader and the Gospel choir, but if your church doesn’t normally lead worship in that style, I wouldn’t try to add it for just this song. The song ends quietly on a note of peace and trust.

…or you can fake the congregation out and then build back up for another few bridges! šŸ˜‚

The rhythms of this song are pretty straightforward, and there aren’t any super crazy chords (unless you do the second ending, in which you’ll need to watch out for some jazzy Gospel additions to the progression). The timing of the chord changes is a little tricky on the choruses, so it’s probably worth taking a minute to get the band on the same page about them.

Conclusions

Will it worship? Maybe.

This is a powerful and deeply moving song. It exalts the power of Jesus and declares his name into all kinds of circumstances. We can and should speak the name of Jesus often and in many different ways! I just hope that we’re teaching our congregations to speak his name reverently in prayer, declaration, and invitation rather than presumptuously as a magic word of faith.

Image by Thomas SchĆ¼tze from Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

KIND – Cory Asbury

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment


I’ve been a Cory Asbury fan since his IHOP days. “So Good to Me” and “Where I Belong” were impactful songs for me during my high school days, “Reckless Love” is a classic, and “The Father’s House” is one of my recent worship faves (I should really write blogs about both of those. Everybody loves to argue about whether God’s love is reckless or not! šŸ¤“). But “Kind” isn’t just a Cory song; it also benefits from the writing talents of Jesse Reeves, Paul Mabury, and Steve Fee.

I stumbled upon “Kind” when my wife sent it to me on TikTok in February this year. Since then, it’s been published on his most recent album Pioneer. A far cry from the goofball antics that often populate Cory’s social media, “Kind” is a heartbreaking testimony of trying to find God’s goodness in the midst of sin and pain. In this blog, I’m not just trying to discern whether a song is true or good but whether it will be beneficial in most corporate worship services. So, is “Kind” biblical? And is it appropriate for Sunday worship? Let’s find out!

Focus

This song is about our doubt, sin, and pain, and God’s response of kindness toward us, specifically in the cross of Christ.

“Kind” spends a lot of words talking about “me.” It takes a first-person perspective to intimately reflect on our thoughts, feelings, and experiences. But I don’t think that makes it a self-centered song. The simple phrase “all He’s ever been is kind” stands in sharp contrast to the many words of our striving, failing, and questioning. God’s kindness is magnified by our desperate need for it.

This song mostly refers to God as “He,” assuming that we will know who it’s referring to. In case we don’t, Jesus is identified by name in the chorus.

Lyric Analysis

VERSE 1
The first verse addresses some of the most painful circumstances we experience in this life: divorce, loss of a child, addiction, and praying for healing without receiving it. Rather than making truth claims, this verse expresses personal experience. The singer admits to having doubts about God’s existence and his character, wondering how he decides who should receive healing.

I have mixed feelings about expressing this kind of doubt in worship. On the one hand, everyone experiences doubts on their faith journey. Many people in the Bible also express pain and doubt, including Lazarus’ sisters, David, the psalmists, the Teacher in Ecclesiastes, and Job. While each worshiper may not have suffered the same experiences as the songwriters of “Kind,” this verse casts a wide net for the kinds of things in life that lead us to doubt God. Acknowledging these doubts together in worship reminds us that we’re not alone, and that our doubts don’t make us “bad” Christians or condemn us to hell.

A friend and colleague asked me recently about worship songs for people struggling with their mental health. I found that almost all the songs we sing are positive and celebratory. Even those that acknowledge our pain and sin end on a note of victory. In a sense, that is appropriate, since we believe that the victory of Jesus is the ultimate destiny of creation. But in the here and now, ending every song on a happy note sometimes negates the pain and doubt people are still experiencing.

On the other hand, these kind of doubts certainly don’t praise God, so it just feels weird to sing them in church. Is that a real problem or just my discomfort with difficult emotions? I’m not sure. I do know that praise isn’t the only kind of worship. Trusting God with our doubts, fears, and pain honors him too.

VERSE 2
Where the first verse was focused on suffering and bad circumstances, this verse stressed regret for the wrong things we have done. The singer admits to burning bridges with people, abandoning relationships and situations after making a mess of them. This verse acknowledges that God forgives us for these things, but that we often find it difficult to forgive ourselves for our sins. We sometimes feel that we are somehow worse than everyone else, too broken for God to love. Again, these particular experiences and feelings might not be universal, but they are representative.

CHORUS
The chorus describes more personal experiences, mostly paired as opposites. Sometimes the author has fled from God, and sometimes he has hurt people in his zealotry. He’s been patient and insistent in turns. He’s even gone so far as to “curse His name in anger,” the most provocative line in the song.

Cursing God is mentioned a few times in Scripture, most notably in Job. The title character of this book experiences the loss of his livestock, his health, and even his children. Far from encouraging him, his wife tells him to quiet being so righteous and just “curse God and die.” Job refuses, and the text tells us that to do so would have been sin, but the rest of the book shows us his struggle with his faith (Job 2:9-10). The reward for sin is death, but forgiveness and eternal life can be found in Jesus (Rom. 3:23), and he tells us that even blasphemy will be forgiven (Matt. 12:32). So cursing God is not recommended by this song, and it is not something that all Christians have done per se, but we have all sinned, and we have all dishonored God sometimes in response to our pain and circumstances.

The chorus also contains the primary truth claim of this song: “all He’s ever been is kind.” But is God only ever kind? Paul seems to push back on this in Romans 11:11-24. In verse 22, he says, “Note then the kindness and the severity of God: severity toward those who have fallen, but God’s kindness to you, provided you continue in his kindness. Otherwise you too will be cut off.” So those who cut themselves off from God experience his severity, and those who remain in him experience his kindness. But in the very next verse, we learn that even God’s punishment is intended to bring people back into his family: “even they, if they do not continue in their unbelief, will be grafted in, for God has the power to graft them in again.” There is kindness even in the severity of God.

So the chorus gives us opportunity to acknowledge the ways we have sinned against God, and it tells us that he responds to all of our failings with kindness. At the end of the song we replace the line about cursing God with the admission, “He knows I don’t deserve it, but He’s never changed His mind.” This echoes Paul’s words in Romans 5:8, “God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” Even in the midst of our rebellion and failures, God maintains faithful lovingkindness towards us.

BRIDGE
God’s kindness is not squishy or passive. He does not ignore our sin, but instead bears it himself on the cross. God’s kindness is at the expense of his own Son, also God himself, dying a criminal’s torturous death. This stark image shows us that God’s kindness is not cheap, not will it be mocked or taken advantage of. It is a serious kindness, bent on our redemption at any cost.

Accessibility

The meaning of this song is clear to anyone: God is kind even when we doubt and even in the midst of our pain. There is some risk of misapprehending the line “all He’s ever been is kind,” as an endorsement of cheap grace or a vision of God lacking justice, wrath, or discipline. The bridge does much to counteract this concern. I think a lot of people will be uncomfortable singing, “I’ve cursed His name in anger.”

The range of this song is an octave and a second, which is actually pretty small for contemporary worship. I don’t find the verses especially easy for a congregation to pick up immediately, but the chorus is catchy and 3 times is likely enough to pick it up.

Music

Like the rest of the Pioneer, “Kind” has a country flavor. It relies on acoustic finger-picking, some light snare work (probably with brushes), and simple piano chords for the rhythmic backbone. Steel guitar, bass, and “ooh” vocals fill out the soundscape. The simple, subdued instrumentation is this song’s strength, and church bands who play it should exercise lots of restraint. This is definitely one of those “fragile egg” songs that will break if you aren’t gentle with it.

The chords themselves are simple, but there are a lot of them, so it’s probably worth a couple minutes to make sure everybody in the band is playing them at the same times. Other than that, the song isn’t rhythmically challenging. The lead vocal has some tricky timing.

Conclusions

“Kind” is a powerful song that reflects seriously on the pain and doubt that are part of the human experience. Rather than explaining or minimizing them, it simply places God’s kindness in their midst and reminds us that Jesus suffered too.

I thought this song was going to be a “no.” I thought the blunt and sometimes harsh descriptions of our doubts and pains were too uncomfortable and personal for a worship service. But if the author of Psalm 88 can say express his feelings of loss and abandonment and doubt before God, then maybe we should too. This song honors the suffering and doubt that all Christians experience in a way that few other songs do, and it presents God’s kindness in a clear and unique way. So then I wanted to say “yes!”

But I can’t get past the feeling that this song isn’t very congregational. I also still feel weird that roughly 1/3 of this song’s 26 lines are about God and his character while 2/3 are about our problems. This song could function very meaningfully in a worship service, but (like many testimony songs) it might be better suited to special music than congregational singing. Not everyone can fully identify with all the problems listed in this song, and many people will have a problem confessing to cursing God’s name in anger when that’s something they don’t believe they’ve done.

So after all that, I think we land in “maybe” territory with this one. “Kind” is a beautiful, valuable, insightful song that will continue to minister to many people in the depths of fear, doubt, and pain. It respects those trials by refusing to give them a trite answer, and it glorifies Jesus by declaring his kindness into the midst of them. But I don’t think Sunday-morning congregational singing is the best vehicle for this song to do its work.

Image by Francisco Gonzalez from Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.

LOOK TO THE LAMB – Jesus Culture, Lindy Cofer, Bryan & Katie Torwalt

/ Jason Henry / Leave a comment

It turns out I like songs with lots of words.

“Look to the Lamb” has a lot of words. The people who wrote those words are Bryan Torwalt, Lindy Cofer, Mitch Wong, and Tommy Iceland. Jesus Culture released it as a single in March of this year, and then again on their album Why Not Right Now? in July.

This song captured my attention with its irresistible energy and the soaring exhortation, “look to the Lamb!” and held it with the deep scriptural imagery and theology of its lyrics. Let’s dive into those lyrics and ask if “Look to the Lamb” is biblical and if it will worship!

Focus

“Look to the Lamb” is about Jesus: his identity, his work of redemption, and especially his glory & worth as depicted in Revelation. It calls him King, the Way to the Father, the Life and Resurrection, the Lamb, the Son of God, the Savior, Alpha & Omega, the Christ, and our God. There is no “I” or “me” in this song, but we sing it to one another, exhorting our fellow believers to see Jesus and worship him.

Lyric Analysis

VERSE 1
Jesus is highly exalted and worthy of worship. His name is above every other name (Phil. 2:9). He calls himself the Light of Life (John 8:12).

I think the throne here is the throne we see in Revelation 4-5, since this scene is evoked later in the bridge. If that’s the case, we might have a little bit of Trinitarian confusion in this verse. It seems that we are calling Jesus the King on the throne, but in Revelation 5, God the Father is the one seated on the throne giving the scroll to the Lamb (Rev. 5:6-7). Jesus is God, and the Father is God, and God is the only King on the throne, so there’s not really a problem here, it’s just odd that this one line describes the Father while the rest of the song is specific to Christ the Son.

VERSE 2
Jesus himself tells us that no one can come to the Father apart from him (John 14:6). He also calls himself the Resurrection and the Life (John 11:25).

In Ezekiel, God tells his people that their hearts are like stone: dead, stubborn, and refusing to worship or listen to him. But he promises that one day he will send his Spirit to dwell in his people and soften their stone hearts (Ezek. 36:24-28). This songs says that it is Jesus’ love that melts our stone hearts. A little different from Ezekiel’s words, but Jesus and the Father send the Holy Spirit, an act of love, so it seems like a good use of this biblical imagery to me (John 15:26).

CHORUS
“Look to the Lamb! // See the Son of God, the Savior crucified // see the crown of thorns, his nails, his wounded side”

What lamb are we looking to? Jesus! Specifically, Jesus as the slain lamb in Revelation 5. He is the Son of God and the Savior. We also get a short, vivid picture of his suffering and passion: the author invites us to see the crown of thorns on his head, the nails piercing his hands and feet, the spear puncturing his side (John 19:2,18,24). Because of this saving work, we call him worthy.

The second half of the chorus focuses on Jesus’ eternal glory. It draws attention to his eyes, where the author finds both love and fire. The love is a no-brainer. God is love, so of course there is love in Jesus’ eyes when he looks at us (1 John 4:8, Zeph. 3:17). But what’s the fire about? We’ll look at that when we get to the bridge. And what exactly is he worthy of? Be patient, I’m getting there!

My favorite thing about this chorus is that it parallels Paul’s line of thought in Philippians 2:5-11. Because Jesus became a man and suffered humbly on our behalf, he is exalted and given the name above every other name. Jesus’ glory flows out of his suffering.

VERSE 3:
The first two lines of this verse are exactly how God describes himself in Revelation 1:8. As alpha and omega are the first and last letters of the Greek alphabet, so Jesus is the first and last of all existence; everything comes from him and is for him (Rev. 22:13, Rom. 11:36). Saying that Jesus “was and is and is to come,” means that he always has existed, exists right now, and always will. This seems like a reference to the name God gives himself at the burning bush: I Am (Ex. 3:13-14). The author of Revelation expands this present-tense name into the past and future, because God is forever and ever.

I can’t find a specific Scripture that talks about shouting at Jesus’ return, but he will return in glory and power with a host of angels (Matt. 25:31), so it’s hard to imagine that there won’t be triumphal shouts far louder than the cries of “hosanna” during his Palm Sunday entrance to Jerusalem (John 12:13). Verse 3 concludes with our own shout identifying the object of our praise as Jesus, both Christ and God (2 Pet. 1:1).

BRIDGE
“The elders bow, the creatures cry // saints and angels glorify”

I discussed this song with one of my team members before introducing it to our church and asked him what he thought the bridge was about. He came up with a beautiful description of how the elders are the leaders of the local church, and how it’s important that they set an example for the congregation by bowing to God, and the creatures are everybody else joining in worship together. I had to tell him he was wrong. šŸ˜¬ At this point, it shouldn’t come as a big surprise that these lyrics are a reference to the scene around God’s throne in Revelation 4-5. The four living creatures are angelic beings with way too many eyes that surround God’s throne. The elders mentioned are 24 elders who bow down to the Lamb and cast down their crowns before him. Since there are 12 sons of Israel in the Old Testament and 12 Apostles in the New, I deduce that these 24 elders are meant to represent all of God’s people throughout all time and space. The saints and angels are all the angels, and all of God’s people (Rev. 5:11-14). We also learn that this declaration of God’s glory continues 24/7 (Rev. 4:8).

What about the strange description of Jesus? Fiery eyes, hair like wool, the voice of roaring waters? You guessed it: Revelation!

“Then I turned to see the voice that was speaking to me, and on turning I sawĀ seven golden lampstands,Ā and in the midst of the lampstandsĀ one likeĀ a son of man,Ā clothed with a long robe andĀ with a golden sash around his chest.Ā The hairs of his head were white, like white wool, like snow.Ā His eyes were like a flame of fire,Ā his feet were like burnished bronze, refined in a furnace, andĀ his voice was like the roar of many waters.Ā In his right hand he held seven stars,Ā from his mouth came a sharp two-edged sword, andĀ his face was like the sun shiningĀ in full strength.”

Revelation 1:12-16

These descriptors are meant to convey the majesty and beauty and power of Jesus. Fire in his eyes represents his jealousy over his people and his mighty power; he has the strength to burn up his enemies and refine/purify his people (Zech. 13:9, Zeph. 3:8). Comparing his hair to wool (and snow) is about the color, not the texture. White (or gray) hair is celebrated in the Bible as a symbol of age, wisdom, and righteousness (Pr. 16:31). His voice thunders like many waters, celebrating the power of his word (Ps. 93:4).

If you were part of Revelation’s original audience, these words would have reminded you of another important, psychedelic throne room scene in Daniel 7. Here, God is called the Ancient of Days, and his hair is white like wool or snow, and his throne is fiery. One called the Son of Man appears before him and is given glory and eternal authority over all creation. All God’s enemies are defeated, and he restores his people to share his dominion. So, Revelation 1, Daniel 7, and this song are all showing us the splendor, power, unity, and victory of God the Father and his Son Jesus.

To sum up: the words of the bridge invite us to envision the heavenly throne room at the conclusion of this age, when all creation bows down to the slain, resurrected, glorified Lamb.

TAG
“Worthy is the Lamb!”

Finally, we come to the central line of this song and find that it is a bit ambiguous. What exactly is Jesus worthy of? In general, when a worship song says God is worthy, I think we assume that he’s worthy of our praise, and he is! But he is also worthy of so much more than that. Again, we find a robust answer in Revelation 4 and 5. The 24 elders declare that the Lord God is worthy of glory, honor, and power (Rev. 4:10-11). The myriad angels repeat these of the slain Lamb and add that he is worthy to receive wealth, wisdom, might, and blessing (Rev. 5:11-12).

The last one is easy to skip over, but it’s is also crucial to this passage, Jesus’ identity, and the meaning of this song: the Lamb is worthy to open the scroll. This scroll usher’s in God’s plan for the culmination of his plan; his enemies are judged and defeated and his people are vindicated and saved, made into priests who will reign with him over a restored creation. John weeps because no one can be found to open this scroll, but then the Lion/Lamb appears (Rev. 5:2-5). Jesus is found worthy to open the scroll because he was slain to ransom God’s people from every people and nation (Rev. 5:9-10).

Accessibility

The verses and the chorus are poetic but straightforward. The bridge is the tricky part, relying on an in-depth understanding of Revelation 4-5, and ideally several Old Testament metaphors. Throughout the song, it’s not apparent exactly what Jesus is worthy of, though we repeatedly call him worthy. So there will be significant gaps in understanding for most congregants. People might try to fill these in with their own assumptions, and they may be wrong, but I don’t see any danger of false theology here. I would encourage worship leaders to use this song as an opportunity to explain some of these metaphors and connections to help people grow in their understanding of Jesus and his glory.

The melody is mostly stepwise with several big skips. So it’s challenging to lead, but it’s pretty easy for the congregation to pick up on and sing along with. Also, the congregation doesn’t have to leap up as high as Lindy Cofer on the latter part of the song, so that helps reduce the range to about an octave.

Music

Classic worship song dynamic arc, builds great; I love the high descant part that the lead vocalist sings during the last bridge and chorus. Unfortunately, part of the vocal work that makes this song so exciting also makes it really challenging for your lead singer! The range works out to an octave+4 The melody line is one of this songs big strengths; it’s engaging and fun without being too difficult to learn.

The chord changes in this song are frequent and almost hymn-like. This has the advantage of making the song feel timeless and fresh, but it also makes it pretty tricky for guitars and keys, especially if you transpose it to any key other than C! Expect to take some time to work through the chord changes with your instrumentalists to make sure they’re all falling at the same time.

Conclusions

Will it worship? Yes!

I think worship songs should be accessible while still teaching us and challenging us to grow in our understanding of God and his word. This song emphatically does both. It is passionate in its worship of Jesus, and I love the way it anchors his glory and final victory in his redemptive work on the cross.

My only reservation with this song is its difficulty for the lead vocalist and band members. If your worship team is up for it, give it a go!

Image by Josh Eckstein from Unsplash

Scripture quotations are from the ESVĀ® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard VersionĀ®), Copyright Ā© 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. May not copy or download more than 500 consecutive verses of the ESV Bible or more than one half of any book of the ESV Bible.